Does God Forbid Debt?
As Americans, we have to admit that we’re in a mess when it comes to debt. Consider the following statistics:
• Average Americans (with debt) were carrying a balance of $135,768 as of late 2018*
• Total personal debt in America is currently over $23 trillion, higher than our national debt*
• Student loans total over $1.5 trillion**
• 4-year college grads average over $37,000 in student loans**
• Around 11% of student loan borrowers are in “serious default” (more than 90 days late)**
The student loan default statistic doesn’t include those making reduced, income-based payments that likely have the borrower paying less than the amount of interest being accrued on their outstanding debt. Should I mention that student loans aren’t dismissed in bankruptcy either?
Debt is clearly all around us and odds are you even have a little following you around as well. Because of its popularity, we need to understand what God has to say about this topic. As a starting point, let’s define debt as simply being the process of getting something now by agreeing to pay for it later. I like this definition because it highlights the relationship of time and debt.
Consider the following verses that speak to the relationship of time and debt:
• Proverbs 20:25 – “It is a trap for a man to dedicate something rashly and only later to consider his vows.”
• Proverbs 27:1 – “Do not boast about tomorrow, for you do not know what a day may bring.”
• James 4:13-16 – “Come now, you who say, ‘Today or tomorrow, we shall go to such and such a city, and spend a year there and engage in business and make a profit.’ Yet you do not know what your life will be like tomorrow. You are just a vapor that appears for a little while and then vanishes away. Instead, you ought to say, ‘If the Lord wills, we shall live and also do this or that.’ As it is, you boast and brag. All such boasting is evil.”
We can see from these verses that we need to take time seriously and also recognize that we’re not the one in control of it. God is sovereign and He controls time. We have no knowledge and no control of what tomorrow brings. We’re only managers of the time that’s been given to us, just like we’re managers of the money God has entrusted to us. Both of these resources are temporary, but time is the more precious of the two because we can’t make more of it. We can use our time to make more money, but we can’t use our money to buy more time. When we go into debt, we bind our time because now we are obligated to use some of our time to earn the money needed to pay off the loan. Do we really want to encumber our future time when we don’t yet know what opportunities God may present to us tomorrow? I’ve seen too many people ignore God’s calling on their lives simply because they had already committed their future to paying off debt.
You’ll likely be relieved to know that God does not categorically forbid borrowing. That’s a good thing too because as a practical matter, a lot of daily life revolves around the availability of some form of credit. Think of all the ways you get the use of something you didn’t pay for in advance (rental cars, hotel rooms, credit cards you pay off at the end of the month, etc.). Technically, all of these situations are available because of the existence of debt.
There are two sides to every debt, the borrower and the lender. While we often think about debt from the side of the borrower, there are a couple of verses in the Old Testament that address debt from the lending side.
• Exodus 22:25 – “If you lend money to one of my people among you who is needy, do not treat it like a business deal; charge no interest.”
• Psalm 37:25-26 – “I have been young, and now am old, yet I have not seen the righteous forsaken or his children begging for bread. He is ever lending generously, and his children become a blessing.”
• Psalm 112:5 – “It is well with the man who deals generously and lends; who conducts his affairs with justice.”
In the New Testament, we even see Jesus encouraging lending in Luke 6:35 where he says “love your enemies, do good to them, and lend to them without expecting to get anything back”.
From these verses, we can see that lending is not forbidden and from that we can conclude it must be okay to borrow as well. Otherwise, the act of lending would be leading people into sin and we would not be encouraged to take part.
On a side note, we can learn a lot about biblical lending from those previous verses. I see two main principles taught in them:
1. Don’t charge your brothers or sisters in Christ interest when they’re in need of a loan.
2. Don’t lend with the expectation of getting the money back.
I believe both of these principles of lending are designed to safeguard the relationship. If you ever want to end a friendship, just loan someone money and expect to make a profit and be paid on time. Anyone with experience of loaning money to a friend or family member understands the pitfalls that go with that arrangement.
It normally doesn’t take long before we have the other person’s financial life under a microscope. From there, it’s easy to get frustrated at the way they’re choosing to spend their (our) money. This response is validation of what we read in Proverbs 22:7 where it says “The rich rule over the poor, and the borrower is servant to the lender.”
It doesn’t matter how good the friendship was before, the servant and master roles are instituted when the loan is created and it takes a solid effort for a relationship to survive that situation. However, if we can go into the lending arrangement with a biblical perspective where we don’t have a profit motive and we consider the money as a gift instead of a loan, we’ll ensure our hearts are in the right place and only be pleasantly surprised when our friend pays us back.
While it’s not necessarily a sin when we borrow, unfortunately our debt can commonly be a result of sinful behavior. We need to objectively review the debt we have and ask ourselves if it’s a result of a sinful heart filled with greed, impatience, coveting or even a lack of faith in God’s provision.
Taking on debt can also be a sin when we wrongly presume upon God. The most common example I see is when we sinfully try to obligate God to pay for things He hasn’t promised. In fact, He may actually be against the things we purchased, but we never took the time to pray and seek His will. Instead, we rushed out, used debt to make the purchase (supposedly on faith) and then told God that we’re trusting in His provision to pay it off. In this instance, we’re treating God more like a genie in a bottle than as the Sovereign God of the universe.
In the end, debt is a tricky topic. It’s a very common part of our society. We see our friends, co-workers, companies and governments using it without a second thought. It’s also easy for us to rationalize the use of it in our own lives. God doesn’t take the issue quite so lightly though. While He gives us the grace to enter into such arrangements, He also provides plenty of warnings of the consequences that can quickly befall us when we don’t take it seriously enough. Relationships can be damaged and ultimately, the condition of our heart can be compromised. With all things considered, I would conclude that debt is something every Christian is better off avoiding whenever possible. Debt is absolutely a form of slavery and any time we voluntarily make ourselves a slave to someone other than Christ, we put our future opportunities to glorify God at risk.
Statistics in this article are from the following sources:
* 2018 American Household Credit Card Debt Study, December 2018 by Claire Tsosie and Erin El Issa
** Student Loan Debt Statistics In 2018: A $1.5 Trillion Crisis, June 2018 by Zack Friedman
Brad Graber, CFP® has been working with clients on personal financial planning and investment issues since 1996. He invests his time mentoring and educating individuals on ways to be better stewards of the resources God has entrusted to them.
[…] the previous article, Does God Forbid Debt?, we concluded that God doesn’t categorically forbid us from taking on debt. That being said, we […]
These days, we are prone to think of our money rather than realizing we are stewards of God’s money. Once we’ve see ourselves as stewards, we are more likely to hold those funds entrusted to us loosely and be generous.
Very interesting in this article how it discusses the strain that can be put on a friendship that loans/borrows money. “It doesn’t matter how good the friendship was before, the servant and master roles are instituted when the loan is created and it takes a solid effort for a relationship to survive that situation.” The loan must be considered a gift to ensure our hearts are in the right place. Good stuff.
“We can use our time to make more money, but we can’t use our money to buy more time. When we go into debt, we bind our time because now we are obligated to use some of our time to earn the money needed to pay off the loan.” Fantastic, I had never seen it like that before. Our ministry opportunities are directly hindered by our loan obligations. Helpful!
This article was helpful in that it really challenges you to think biblically about your motives as both a lender and a borrower. If the end result is to glorify God through our actions (ICor. 10:31) even when it comes to borrowing, it would be a good idea to be very prayerful, yield to sound biblical counsel and use godly wisdom with every situation that will result in being in debt.
I really appreciate how debt is defined in this article, “the process of getting something now by agreeing to pay for it later,” and how the author heightens the readers’ awareness of the negative, or detrimental affect, that being in debt can have on “our time” (time we have because it has been entrusted to us by God). Being under the non-negotiating responsibility of debt, our time is obligated to be used to pay off said debt.The Bible verses quoted in this article have really given me cause to stop, pause, and consider, and to ultimately desire all the more a better understanding on how God views borrowing and lending, so that I can navigate within these two realms in a way that would, first and foremost, reflect a heart that loves & obeys God: trusts in His provision, searchers out my heart’s motive, and seeks Biblical truth & wise counsel. Debt, yes, is a common part of our society, but I would never consider taking advice or counsel from mainstream society in many areas of life (divorce, marriage, homosexuality, fairness, sex, abortion, gambling, etc.), so why would I blindly follow the “society’s norm” when it comes to how, why, and when I spend, borrow, and lend my money? So in this case of debt, spending, borrowing, and lending money, AND time, I want it to be informed by the Scriptures.
So true–I do not want my financial actions and attitudes to be informed by our society any more than the other areas you mentioned. There is great biblical wisdom presented in this article!
[…] with Kelli and Linda” on Moody Radio Indiana (97.9 FM). You can read the corresponding articles Does God Forbid Debt and The Intangible Costs of […]
This article helped me see the importance of borrowing and lending wisely. It can be easy to do both rashly and hastily, and that is why we must examine our motives for each and make sure they line up with Scripture!
Does God forbid debt? That depends on the nature of the debt. Acquiring a loan for education in order to better your ability to earn an income might be an example of a ‘good’ debt. However, even that can be abused. I personally know of two people who sought out education loans and got them, then dropped out of school. “They give you free money” one of them told me. Neither had any intention of paying the loans back. The last estimate I saw was that 40% of education loans will not be repaid.
Buying a house and acquiring a mortgage could also be a ‘good’ debt as your family needs a place to live and you will gain no equity if you only rent. Even so, this also can be abused. Buying a house you cannot afford could ultimately cost you. I sometimes hear the phrase “dream house” meaning we saw it (the house) and we just ‘had’ to have it without regard to its price.
Buying the newest phone just because it’s new and you want one, while your existing and cheaper phone does everything you need for work or home, could be an example of a bad debt. Likewise, if you can only afford ‘that’ car if you take out an 80 month loan, you really should take another hard look at that.
We need to learn to clearly distinguish between our actual needs and our wants.